Article by: Jessica McLane Gann, Founder, Salt and Birch

---

 The Loyalty You Earn Tomorrow Depends on the Adaptations You Begin Today.   

The modern marketplace is experiencing an unprecedented generational convergence, with six distinct consumer segments actively shaping industries, including nonprofits and associations. From the Silent Generation to Gen Alpha, each group brings unique values, expectations, and engagement preferences. While corporations with deep pockets invest heavily in tailoring experiences for each demographic, nonprofits and associations—often constrained by limited resources—must still deliver compelling, high-value member experiences.

The Generations in the Marketplace

• Silent Generation (1928–1945): Traditional, brand-loyal, values trust and legacy.
• Baby Boomers (1946–1964): Seek impact-driven engagement and high-quality service.
• Gen X (1965–1980): Prioritizes ROI, professional growth, and networking.
• Millennials (1981–1996): Digital-first, experience-driven, and socially conscious.
• Gen Z (1997–2012): Values authenticity, quick access, and interactive content.
• Gen Alpha (2013–2025): The youngest, influencing parental decisions and digital natives.

Commonalities Across Generations

Despite their differences, all generations share some key expectations and behaviors when it comes to nonprofit engagement:

• Technology Integration: While their preferred platforms may differ, all generations now rely on technology for engagement, whether through email, websites, social media, or mobile apps.
• Value-Oriented Decision Making: Members and donors of all ages want to see the tangible impact of their contributions and expect transparency from organizations.
• Personalized Experiences: Each generation values content and experiences tailored to their interests, whether it’s event programming, communication styles, or membership perks.
• Community and Connection: Whether through in-person gatherings, online communities, or hybrid experiences, people of all ages seek meaningful engagement with like-minded individuals.
• Trust in Institutions: While trust may be declining among younger generations, every age group still places importance on credibility, authenticity, and ethical leadership in organizations.

Distinct Differences Among Generations

While commonalities exist, each generation has unique expectations and engagement styles:

• Silent Generation & Baby Boomers: Prefer traditional engagement methods, including direct mail, in-person networking, and formal communication. They are more likely to donate through legacy giving or structured membership models.
• Gen X: Values efficiency and flexibility. They appreciate in-depth content like reports and webinars but expect digital convenience in accessing resources.
• Millennials: Prioritize experiences over long-term commitments. They are more likely to support causes through crowdfunding, one-time donations, and event participation rather than annual memberships.
• Gen Z: Digital natives who demand fast, interactive, and mobile-first engagement. They respond best to short-form video, social media advocacy, and gamified experiences.
• Gen Alpha: While still young, they are shaping nonprofit engagement through their parents’ decisions and early exposure to social responsibility via technology.

The Changing Attitudes Toward Membership and Nonprofits

Historically, membership associations, certification bodies, and nonprofit organizations have thrived on legacy models—offering exclusive benefits, professional networking, and advocacy. However, shifting consumer attitudes are reshaping expectations:

• Gen Z and Millennials are skeptical of traditional membership models. They prioritize access over ownership and value experiences over credentials. They expect engagement to be digital-first, interactive, and socially impactful.
• Gen X values stability and ROI. While they appreciate professional development, networking, and accreditation, they also demand a tangible return on investment in memberships and donations.
• Boomers and the Silent Generation are brand-loyal but evolving. They have traditionally been the backbone of nonprofit support but are now more selective about where they allocate their resources, demanding measurable impact and efficient use of funds.

For nonprofits and associations, the challenge is clear: evolve or risk obsolescence.

Key Strategies for Staying Relevant Across Generations

1. Rethink Value Propositions for a Diverse Audience: Instead of a one-size-fits-all approach, organizations must develop segmented value propositions tailored to each generation’s motivations. This requires:

• Digital-first engagement for younger generations (Gen Z, Millennials)
• Professional growth and ROI-driven benefits for Gen X
• Legacy, credibility, and impact-driven messaging for Boomers and older members

2. Innovate Membership Models: Membership structures must evolve beyond annual dues and static benefits. Consider:

• Freemium Models: Offering basic access with premium paid tiers for deeper engagement.
• On-Demand Memberships: Flexible, pay-as-you-go structures that align with changing work and lifestyle preferences.
• Cause-Based Communities: Aligning with social causes that resonate with younger audiences.

3. Embrace Digital Transformation: Associations and nonprofits must meet members where they are—online. This means:

• Seamless, mobile-friendly engagement experiences
• AI-driven personalization to curate content and benefits
• Data-driven insights to understand member behaviors and preferences

Adapt, Innovate, or Decline

The expectations for nonprofit and association experiences now rival those of commercial brands. Organizations that resist change will struggle to retain and attract members, while those that innovate will cultivate thriving, engaged communities. 

The path forward is clear: embrace generational diversity, rethink value delivery, and leverage technology to create meaningful connections.

Call to Action: What Should Nonprofit Leaders Do Now?

1. Conduct a Generational Membership Audit: Identify gaps in engagement and value delivery.
2. Pilot a Digital-First Initiative: Start with small-scale programs like a mobile-friendly newsletter or virtual networking event.
3. Reassess Content & Communication Strategies: Ensure messaging resonates with all generations.
4. Bring in Outside Thought Leadership: Leverage external expertise through consultants, industry experts, and specialized staff to drive innovation, uncover blind spots, and implement best practices.

For nonprofits and associations, the choice is simple—evolve or become irrelevant.

How Salt and Birch Can Help

Salt and Birch helps nonprofits apply these insights to build smarter strategies, modernize engagement, and grow across generations—without breaking the budget.